Shincheonji Church Challenges French Media Portrayal, Demands Balanced Reporting

The Shincheonji Church of Jesus in France has strongly contested a recent Le Parisien newspaper article, claiming the report unfairly characterized the religious organization and its members. The church argues that the April 7 article, titled 'They Treated Us Like Animals,' presented a distorted narrative based primarily on unverified claims from anonymous former members.

The church's primary criticism centers on the article's reporting methodology, noting that while they provided comprehensive written responses to 12 journalistic queries, less than 1% of their perspective was included in the final publication. Church representatives emphasized that the rapid four-hour turnaround between their submission and the article's publication suggested a predetermined narrative.

To counter the negative portrayal, the church presented testimonials from current members highlighting positive experiences. Teresa, a six-year church attendee in Paris, described her involvement as a voluntary journey of spiritual growth, while another member, Axel, credited the church with helping him discover life's meaning and even meeting his wife.

The church categorically denied several allegations, including claims of data collection, internet restrictions, and family isolation. They stressed that participation in church activities, including a previously existing spiritual training program, was always voluntary and participants could leave at any time.

Specific allegations, such as a photo purportedly showing disciplinary punishment, were explained as misrepresentations. The church noted the individual in the photograph plans to file an official complaint about the unauthorized and misleading use of his image.

Beyond defending their reputation, the church called for more responsible media reporting, urging journalists to provide inclusive coverage that reflects diverse perspectives, respects religious freedom, and avoids sensationalism. They emphasized the importance of fair representation and ethical reporting practices when covering religious communities.

This dispute highlights broader challenges in media representation of religious organizations and the delicate balance between investigative journalism and fair portrayal of faith communities. The church's robust response underscores the potential consequences of one-sided reporting and the ongoing need for nuanced, balanced media coverage.